Seventh Domain Analysis Clinic

The Seventh Domain Analysis Clinic—Interdisciplinary Studies—began as a question shared between Associate Fellow Rick Szostak and Senior Fellow Richard Smiraglia. 2024 saw publication of two meta-level anthologies about the field of Interdisciplinary Studies. These are The Edward Elgar Encyclopedia of Interdisciplinarity and Transdisciplinarity (F. Darbellay ed.), and The Edward Elgar Handbook of Interdisciplinary Teaching and Administration (R. Szostak, ed.). The question arose, what sort of ontical clusters might be observed through domain analytic visualization. The fascinating first results point to strong invisible colleges in the domain.

Szostak and Smiraglia have completed an initial paper for the 2025 NASKO Conference “A Domain Analytic View of Interdisciplinary Studies” (North American Symposium on Knowledge Organization
June 19-20, 2025, Online conference sponsored by the University of Western Ontario, Canada) https://iskocus.org/nasko2025-program.php .

Data collected were sufficient to support further research, including evolution of a nascent taxonomy of interdisciplinary studies. The clinic’s call for research is quoted from the NASKO paper (p. 3):

A key motive for the present study is to see whether there is still a tendency for scholars within the global community to cite those with a similar organizational pedigree. Do AIS scholars tend to cite each other, while td-net scholars cite each other also? If so, are there key scholars that bridge these communities? Note that these divisions are not entirely regional. There are European universities that have long interacted with AIS and use textbooks developed within AIS. There are some North Americans with strong links to td-net. Note that both Darbellay and Szostak, the editors of the two volumes under consideration here, have long had connections with all of the organizations noted above, though Szostak is more closely associated with AIS. This is reflected in the two volumes, with AIS members providing about half of the Handbook chapters but only perhaps a fifth of Encyclopedia entries.

References

Darbellay, Frédéric, ed. 2024. The Edward Elgar Encyclopedia of Interdisciplinarity and Transdisciplinarity. Cheltenham UK: Edward Elgar.

Szostak, Rick, ed. 2024. The Edward Elgar Handbook of Interdisciplinary Teaching and Administration. Cheltenham UK: Edward Elgar.

Szostak, Rick and Richard P. Smiraglia. 2025. “A Domain Analytic View of Interdisciplinary Studies.” Paper accepted for North American Symposium on Knowledge Organization (NASKO 2025), online conference, Univ. of Western Ontario, June 19-20, 2025. 

Clinic Participants

Richard P. Smiraglia is Senior Fellow and Executive Director of IKOS.

Rick Szostak is Associate Fellow of IKOS. He is Professor of Economics at the University of Alberta.